CasaGiga 454 (Maiano)

We stayed here for two nights in June during our trip through Italy, and to say it was the highlight of our journey would be an understatement. From the moment we arrived until we reluctantly departed 48 hours later, we were in complete bliss. The apartment we stayed in was slightly removed from the main building, a truly stunning, authentic Tuscan-style space that instantly made us feel at home. The pool was simply breathtaking, complemented by incredible views and an atmosphere of total peace and tranquility. It has been six months since our visit, and we still speak about this place constantly. Calling it a gem doesn’t quite do it justice. We cannot wait to return next summer. We also brought home some olive oil from the shop, which we use sparingly, saving every drop until we can come back to stock up again. Truly the best. Thank you for such an unforgettable experience.

The Farm and Botanical Gardens are one of a kind. The overlook into Florence and Fiesole is a sight to behold. The food is always fresh. This is a true farm to table dining place. The rooms are actually quite large. The pool is great for the hot days and just to relax. This place is so kid friendly. I see why so many locals come to this place.

Incredibly disappointing - specifically, a horrible experience with the exceptionally rude restaurant manager. I feel robbed of what could have been a lovely evening. We were grossly overcharged as a result of a mistake made by the waitress, and this was subsequently not admitted to and we received no refund (!). We ordered a steak for dinner for 2 people and the waitress told us to order 600g. We ordered 600g. We get the bill and see we were actually served 1.7kg. The mischarged difference was almost 60 euros. Ultimately it's not really about the money. It's the principle. This place treats its customers poorly. Would never stay again and strongly recommend you instead consider one of the many other lovely places to stay in Florence. Rooms are also very gloomy and soulless.